How to Build a Profitable Airbnb Business Without Owning Property

Airbnb Property Arbitrage Business in the U.S.

A Scalable Rental Income Model Without Property Ownership

About the writer

Dickson Wasake has more than 20 years of experience, including with global accounting firms PwC, Baker Tilly, and Deloitte, and various roles such as a fractional CFO and advisor for clients. He is an ex-audit partner (Baker Tilly CI). Dickson is a UK CPA (FCCA)and a US CPA (IL), with experience working with clients of various sizes, ranging from start-ups to a $1.3 trillion listed company. He has travelled to 30+ countries, including Sub-Saharan Africa, the Bahamas, the UK, and Canada. He lives in IL, USA. Connect with him on LinkedIn or view his detailed resume/CV.

🔍 Introduction: Rent It, Furnish It, Profit

In the early days, Airbnb was truly affordable. I recall traveling to Boston to visit a family member and securing a great deal. Now, everyone knows how crazy Boston hotel prices can be, so Airbnb was a really great alternative. Fast forward a few years, when I  moved to Toronto, I managed to get an Airbnb for about 1 month, right near the Scotia Bank arena, home of the Toronto Raptors NBA team (go Raptors!).

Granted, it was a prime location, but the prices in that city were so astronomical, it seemed there was no difference between that and a hotel or any typical apartment. What happened? Has the model matured now?  I believe so, one report shows that the price difference by 2022 was only 26%, but in 2019 it was 43%. 

That said and done, if you are the one leasing out the property, then higher prices is a good thing, but how do you get into the sector, yet you don’t own the property?  That’s when the arbitrage model comes in.

It works like this:

You sign a lease on a two-bedroom apartment in a travel-heavy city like, say, Toronto, Atlanta, or Miami. You furnish it tastefully, list it on Airbnb, and within a few weeks, bookings cover the rent you are paying to the landlord, and leave a margin of $800 to $1,200/month.

The difference between what you pay the landlord and what you receive from bookings is arbitrage, or the price difference.

You repeat the process and just like that you are in the rental arbitrage market.

• U.S. Airbnb market has over 2.5 million active listings (Demand Sage, 2024)

• Rental arbitrage allows you to earn from short-term rentals without owning the property

• Some top earners manage 5–10 units and generate six-figure income

💡 What We Think About This Business

This model is for detail-oriented operators who can manage guest experience, compliance, and landlord relationships. Perfect for urban dwellers or remote managers with systems in place.

“Running an Airbnb business is more akin to running a boutique hotel than being a landlord.”— AirDNA, “How Much Can You Make on Airbnb?”

⚖ SWOT Analysis (Big issues in the Airbnb arbitrage sector)

Category	What It Means	Examples
Strengths	No property purchase required	Lease instead of mortgage
Weaknesses	Lease restrictions, market saturation	Home Owners’ Association (HOA) bans, competition
Opportunities	Urban + vacation zones, mid-term rentals	Nurses, digital nomads
Threats	Local regulations, permit changes	Short-term rental caps, taxes

🧠 Key Things to Know Before You Start

✅ Requirements:

• Written permission from landlord to sublet on Airbnb

• Fully furnished unit (including linens, cookware, Wi-Fi)

• Business license and short-term rental permit (varies by city)

• Listing on Airbnb, Vrbo, or Booking.com

⚠ Risk Management in the Airbnb arbitrage business:

Risk	Risk Management Tool
Lease violations	Legal subletting clause, landlord contract
Guest damages	Security deposits + Airbnb Host Guarantee
Vacancy risk	Dynamic pricing + multi-platform listings
Regulatory bans	Focus on “30+ day stays” in tight markets

🔐 Internal Controls (systems to put in place)

Risk	Control
Calendar overlap	Sync calendars with iCal or channel manager
Cleaning delays	Backup cleaners + checklist system
Guest complaints	24/7 messaging Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) + review filter alerts
Expense mismanagement	Monthly P&L + reserve fund

Typical Founder Concern: “How do I get landlords or capital to trust me?”

Airbnb arbitrage isn’t about listings — it’s about reliability. Investors and landlords want proof you won’t default. Build a simple pitch deck that shows nightly rate assumptions, average occupancy, and cash reserve buffers. Trust isn’t won by charm — it’s earned through modeling.

I want to, at this stage add another very critical warning which anyone venturing into this sector should be concerned about:

⚠️ Critical Risk: Legal & Lease Fragility

I must warn you that Airbnb arbitrage is inherently fragile, especially in cities with aggressive short-term rental regulations. In places like New York, San Francisco, or Barcelona (for global-focused investors), entire business models have collapsed overnight due to rule changes targeting non-owner operators. I once stayed in an Airbnb in Barcelona, but I recall that there was talk of tough regulations to prevent locals from being priced out of the rental market due to Airbnbs being owned by wealthy investors.

This strategy is at its core built on leased properties the operator doesn't own—which means you control revenue but not the underlying asset. A landlord’s decision not to renew, a sudden building policy change, or local legislation can instantly shut down your income stream.

You should not mistake arbitrage for passive income or low-risk real estate. It’s a high-touch hospitality business layered over legal complexity, and long-term success depends on:

• Choosing regulation-friendly markets

• Negotiating lease protections with the landlord

• Diversifying into ownership or co-hosting as you mature.

Treat arbitrage as a launch pad, not an endgame.

Now that I have given you the warnings, let’s continue.

🛠 What the First Few Months Look Like

Month 1–3:

• Research high-demand cities + sublet-friendly buildings

• Negotiate lease + draft addendum with landlord

• Furnish the unit using IKEA, Amazon, and Facebook Marketplace. I love Wayfair, try them (especially during sales!)

• Launch listing with pro photos + write high-converting copy

Typical Week:

• Manage bookings and calendar

• Coordinate cleaning turnover (use apps like TurnoverBnB)

• Handle guest communication + check-in instructions

• Track expenses and revenue per unit

📈 Future Outlook (What’s ahead in the Airbnb arbitrage sector)

• Growth in mid-term rentals (30–90 days) for corporate travel and relocation

• AI-based dynamic pricing tools are increasing yield

• Cities are tightening compliance—an opportunity for compliant operators

🧠 Advanced Thinking Tips (Separating yourself from the competition)

Insights:

• AirDNA: Midterm stays have doubled in 2 years and outperform short stays in many cities

• McKinsey: Travelers now expect “hotel-grade” amenities even in short-term rentals

• OKC Property Manager. Businesses with recurring guest bases, like travel nurses, can be a pretty good option to target.

Strategic Moves:

• Niche down by guest type: traveling professionals (such as nurses), pet owners, relocation clients

• Automate: channel manager, auto-replies, cleaning SOPs

• Offer upsells: bike rental, cleaning kits, grocery delivery

Business Model and Revenue Streams

💰 Start-Up Cost Breakdown (Detailed)

Item	Est. Cost	Notes	Source
Furniture + décor	$5,000	Beds, couch, dining, décor	IKEA, Amazon
Security deposit + 1st month rent	$3,000	$1,500/month average	Zillow
Business license + STR permit	$500	Varies by city	Local city gov
Photos + listing setup	$500	Professional shoot + copywriting	Upwork, Fiverr
Insurance	$300	Host liability and contents insurance	Safely.com
Extra supplies (linen, consumables)	$500	Bedding, kitchen essentials, bathroom essentials, cleaning supplies, safety and comfort, welcome.	Amazon
Smart tech (lockers, routers)	$300	Various
Legal entity set up	$450	Legal zoom
SaaS tools	$1,440	Hospitable or Guestly (guest experience),  Turnover BnB (cleaning), Price labs (dynamic pricing engine), QB (accounting)
Miscellaneous	1,199	10%

Startup Estimate: ~$13,189

💸 Operating Costs & ROI (Annual Estimate)

Assumptions:

• Monthly revenue: $3,264. In the model, I am assuming an Average Daily Rate (ADR) of $155.42. Monthly booking of 21 nights. This yields an occupancy rate of approximately 70% and reflects an advanced-thinking operator utilizing dynamic pricing and various other strategies.

• Monthly expenses: ~$2,200 (rent + cleaning + utilities + platform fees) – see below.

Expense Breakdown (Monthly):

Item	Cost	Notes
Rent	$1,500	Fixed lease
Cleaning	$250	5–6 turns/month
Utilities + Wi-Fi	$150	Flat rate
Platform fees	$100	Airbnb 3% host fee
Miscellaneous	$200	10%

 Net Profit = ~$1064/month or $12,766/year

ROI = $12,766 ÷ $13,189 = ~97% ROI

The ROI means that for every $1 you invest in Year 1, you get $0.97 back! This is not bad to start with, considering you own none of the property!

📊 3-Year View (High Level)

You start with 1 unit, add 1-2 units in year 2 and by year 5 scale to a 5 unit operation.  You are improving your ADR. At this stage you also move to other options like:

·        Keyless entry systems: Operto, Igloohome, August Smart Lock ($100–$200 one-time, or $10–$20/mo integration)

·        Guest experience apps: Touch Stay, Duve

·        Accounting upgrade: QuickBooks Online + integrations, or Short Term Rentals (STR)-specific platforms like Bnbtally

🧰 Recommended Software Stack

• Hospitable, Guesty, or Hostaway (automation)

• TurnoverBnB (cleaning coordination)

• Google Sheets or QuickBooks (bookkeeping)

• Smartbnb, PriceLabs (dynamic pricing)

🌍 Global Outlook: Airbnb Arbitrage & STR Businesses Beyond the U.S.

The Airbnb arbitrage model is gaining traction globally, especially in regions where urban rental demand and tourism intersect. In places like India, Kenya, and Brazil, entrepreneurs lease units in hotspots like Goa, Nairobi, and Rio to target digital nomads and returning expats, often combining STRs with co-hosting or add-on services (e.g. scooters, local tours).

In Europe, stricter regulations in cities like Paris and Amsterdam are pushing operators to pivot toward midterm rentals and corporate housing in secondary cities like Valencia or Porto. Meanwhile, in Africa and Latin America (LATAM), operators rely on WhatsApp, Instagram, and local payment apps to manage bookings and reduce platform fees.

Globally, success depends on localizing listings, using smart pricing tools, and embracing midterm stays for more stable cash flow. Smart operators are diversifying across platforms (Airbnb, Booking.com, local apps), layering tech like Hospitable or TurnoverBnB, and adapting quickly to evolving city regulations.

Conclusion: Should you move into the Airbnb sector immediately?

Airbnb arbitrage offers a strong return on investment (ROI) profile and moderate scalability, making it an attractive option for hands-on entrepreneurs willing to navigate the legal and operational complexities. With startup costs that are reasonable for professionals and increasing global demand for flexible housing, the model is well-positioned for growth—particularly through midterm stays and niche targeting like travel nurses or remote workers.

However, entry is not frictionless. Regulatory restrictions, lease limitations, and the need for landlord approval create real barriers. Day-to-day operations—guest messaging, cleaning, turnover—also require consistency and systems to sustain profitability.

The model works best for those who treat it as a lean hospitality business rather than a passive real estate play. Operators who localize well, leverage tech, and monitor compliance closely can achieve reliable, if not exceptional, returns.

I can now see why the Airbnb costs have started coming closer to the hotel rates, as I observed from my earlier days. Cities didn’t for example regulate it as much as they do now, so that adds costs, plus the costs of cleaning do add up and now with competition the software stack (SaaS) becomes more critical, no wonder it is increasingly the preserve of larger investors and not mom and pop as was initially thought!

🔚 Inachee Index Score: 71/100 – Tier B (Strong)

Attractive for operators who want cash flow without ownership—if you master guest experience and local compliance.

What Is the Inachee Index?

The Inachee Index scores sectors using 8 weighted dimensions: ROI potential, startup accessibility, ease of entry, scalability, compliance, market resilience, future relevance, and execution simplicity. Each sector receives a score out of 100 and is assigned a tier (A–D).

How does this sector rank against all others in the US? Check out the US ranking list. 

Want a more detailed financial model or forecast for this sector? Ask us about financial modelling.

Want Your Sector or Business Reviewed?

Submit your idea to be scored using the Inachee Index:👉 Get a Business Sector Review.

📣 Like this Article? Subscribe to www.inachee.com for expert business insights, startup guides, and ROI-based sector rankings.

Join advanced thinking. We regularly provide insights to our 900+ subscribers on accounting, risk management, marketing, governance, the future of entrepreneurship, and best practice to help you start and grow a profitable business. Gift that transforms business when you sign up.

Love what we do? Perhaps there is a fit globally. See what we look for. 

Disclaimer: While we have taken steps to research this information as well as based on our experience, you should not solely rely on the information given here to base your investment decisions. You should seek business advice from a professional knowledgeable of your specific circumstances. (e.g of your specific location and capital structure). The author (or Inachee) shall therefore not be held responsible for any loss you may incur when acting on this information.